Rules Reform – Ideas for the 120th Congress
At the beginning of each Congress, the House of Representatives agrees on a new set of rules that govern how business in the chamber will be conducted over the next two years. This provides an opportunity for members to adopt a set of rules that encourage fiscal responsibility and shine a light on our nation’s unsustainable fiscal outlook.
In this piece, as we have done prior to previous Congresses, we suggest some practical rule changes that would promote fiscal guardrails and improve transparency regarding the fiscal impact of legislation. These suggestions are oriented toward the House rules process because the Senate does not require a new set of rules at the beginning of each new Congress. However, many of them could be adopted in the Senate as well.
Promoting Fiscal Guardrails
Restore Full Pay-As-You-Go (PAYGO) Rule. House rules currently include a Cut-As-You-Go, or “CUTGO” rule, which bars legislation that increases mandatory spending on net over specified five- and ten-year periods but does not apply the same requirement to tax cuts. The 120th Congress should replace CUTGO with a full PAYGO rule covering both changes in direct spending and changes in revenues and model it on the Senate’s PAYGO rule, creating a point of order against violating PAYGO. Ideally, a waiver of this rule would require a separate three-fifths vote.
Enhance Transparency and Enforcement of PAYGO. House rules should require the House Reading Clerk to read a statement on whether legislation violates PAYGO rules or Statutory PAYGO. Furthermore, the PAYGO rule should have a high waiver threshold. Any waiver should require a separate, recorded vote preceded by dedicated debate.
Restore the “Conrad Rule” to prevent reconciliation from increasing deficits. From 2007 through 2015, Senate rules prohibited reconciliation bills from adding to the deficit over a five- or ten-year period. The Fiscal Year 2016 budget resolution repealed this rule – known as the “Conrad Rule.” The House should revive this rule in the incoming Congress, and the Senate should follow suit.
Improving Transparency
Adopt “No Score, No Vote” and Allow 24 Hours for Review. The House should prohibit consideration of legislation until a comprehensive estimate of its fiscal impact from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) or the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) has been made available to the public for at least 24 hours. To waive this point of order, the House should require a standalone vote and should not allow it to be waived in a special rule. Congress should also provide CBO and JCT the resources necessary to meet this new requirement.
Establish a Fiscal State of the Nation Presentation with the Comptroller General. House rules should require the House Budget Committee to use its jurisdiction over fiscal matters to convene an annual joint public hearing with the Senate Budget Committee to hear testimony from the Government Accountability Office’s Comptroller General on the “fiscal state of the nation.” Such testimony would give members a comprehensive look at the fiscal health of the nation using non-partisan fiscal and economic projections.
Display a National Debt Clock on the House Floor. Keeping a current national debt monitor in the House chamber will ensure that members always have our nation’s fiscal situation in mind when debating legislation.
Conclusion
As one of the first actions taken at the start of a new Congress, the House rules package provides an important opportunity to lay the groundwork for fiscally responsible lawmaking over the following two years. If Congress sets rules for itself that strongly encourage fiscal responsibility, then it’s more likely Congress will behave in a fiscally responsible way.
Of course, rules alone do not guarantee fiscally responsible decision-making. Many of the rules we suggest in this piece have been adopted in the past only to have been routinely waived or ignored. It is ultimately up to individual members to abide by the rules they set for themselves and to party leadership to enforce them.
Given our high and rising debt and deficits, however, it’s more important than ever that lawmakers do what is necessary to ensure we start fixing our fiscal problems instead of making them worse. Legislation to address revenue and spending will be needed, along with efforts to set a fiscal target (such as reducing deficits to 3% of Gross Domestic Product), enact a bipartisan fiscal commission to tackle our largest budget challenges, and ensure long-term solvency for trust fund programs like Social Security and Medicare. Congress can start getting it right on Day 1 by endorsing the right set of rules to help them achieve those things.